antropologi.info - anthropology in the news blog

    Nordisk | Auf Deutsch | Anthropology Newspaper | Anthropology Journal Ticker | Journals | Contact

Germanic Y-chromosomes? Racial theories still alive?

by lorenz on Jul 19, 2006 in Us and Them, anthropology (general)

(via Livejournal Anthropologist Community) What? Germanic Y-chromosomes? What's that? And "Germanic genes"? Are racial theories alive and kicking?

The BBC writes about an "abundance of Germanic genes in England today":

There are a very high number of Germanic male-line ancestors in England's current population. Genetic research has revealed the country's gene pool contains between 50 and 100% Germanic Y-chromosomes.

Or what are "native British genes"?

"We believe that they [Anglo Saxons] also prevented the native British genes getting into the Anglo-Saxon population by restricting intermarriage in a system of apartheid that left the country culturally and genetically Germanised."

We don't get any explanations on how these genes are defined. Race - as we know - "doesn't exist biologically, but it does exist socially," as anthropologist Alan Goodman once said. "Human populations are not unambiguous, clearly demarcated, biologically distinct groups" (AAA-Statement on Race). But reading the articles in the BBC and New Scientist, it seems that race has become a biological reality.

UPDATE (20.7.06): Comment by Alex Golub at Savage Minds:

There are things that I find curious about the article—the assumption that ‘marriage’ and ‘reproduction’ are the same thing and that ethnic identity is always corelated with a genetic marker for instance—but there doesn’t seem to be very much to be ‘racial’ to me.

>> read the whole comment

SEE ALSO:

Race again: Anthropologist Kerim Friedman comments on controversial article

"It will take a long time for people to grasp the illusory nature of race"

Anthropology and Race - Discussions in the Classroom

Savage Minds: Recent Debates on Race and Class

Racism: The Five Major Challenges for Anthropology

American Anthropological Association Statement on "Race" and Race - A Scholars' Preview

This entry was posted by admin and filed under Us and Them, anthropology (general).
  • « E-mail has become the new snail mail - Text Messaging on Rise
  • A link between food resources and social hierarchies? »

4 comments

Comment from: Rex

Rex

Fulltext of the PDF is available here for free:
http://www.pubs.royalsoc.ac.uk/media/proceedings_b/papers/RSPB20063627.pdf

2006-07-19 @ 21:20

Comment from: lorenz

admin

Thanks! I’m not much wiser after reading it, though

2006-07-20 @ 01:01

Comment from: Ahrimahn

Ahrimahn

Are you saying that it is racist to point out that Britain had a pre-Anglo-Saxon population? Is it also racist to point out that the Americas and South Africa had pre-European populations?

2006-07-20 @ 17:04

Comment from: lorenz

admin

Of course not. I was just wondering about the use of terms like “native British genes” and “Germanic Y-chromosomes” that suggest a biologic understanding of ethnicity.

2006-07-20 @ 19:03


Form is loading...

Search

Recent blog posts

  • antropologi.info is 20 years old - some (unfinished) notes and thoughts
  • More dangerous research: Anthropologist detained, beaten, forcibly disappeared in Egypt
  • When research becomes dangerous: Anthropologist facing jail smuggles himself out over snowy mountains
  • In Europe, more than two thirds of all academic anthropologists are living in precarity
  • Globalisation and climate change in the High Arctic: Fieldwork in Svalbard, the fastest-heating place on earth

Recent comments

  • mace on Hmong: An Endangered People
  • Joe Patterson on Anthropologists condemn the use of terms of "stone age" and "primitive"
  • lorenz on Anthropologists condemn the use of terms of "stone age" and "primitive"
  • Chris Healy on Anthropologists condemn the use of terms of "stone age" and "primitive"
  • lorenz on Businesses, advertising firms turn to commercial ethnography

Categories

  • All

Retain only results that match:

XML Feeds

  • RSS 2.0: Posts, Comments
  • Atom: Posts, Comments
What is RSS?

User tools

  • Admin

©2025 by Lorenz Khazaleh • Contact • Help • Multi-blog engine